Two Paisan's Pizzeria & Cafe: Authentic NYC Style Pizza in Rochester

Top categories (Pizza / Calzones&Rolls / PIZZA AND WINGS COMBO / Hot& Cold Subs / Appetizers)
Most orders: $10–20

Located in the heart of Rochester, NY, Two Paisan's Pizzeria & Cafe is a standout destination for pizza lovers craving an authentic New York City-style pie. This pizza restaurant masterfully delivers on its promise of genuine Italian-American flavors, blending traditional techniques with fresh, high-quality ingredients. From the moment you step inside or order to-go, the inviting aroma of baked dough, melted cheese, and rich garlic wafts through the air, setting the stage for an exceptional dining experience.

The star of the menu is undoubtedly their pizza, praised again and again by customers for its perfect balance of crispy crust and soft chewiness — a true Brooklyn-style masterpiece. Each slice boasts a harmonious mix of house-made sauce and freshly grated cheese, creating layers of flavor that feel both comforting and vibrant. For those who want to explore beyond pizza, the pasta selections offer a sincere nod to Italian classics. Whether you indulge in a creamy Alfredo or the robust Meatball Parm, the dishes are thoughtfully prepared, delivering warmth and satisfaction with every bite. Their baked pasta options, such as the Baked Ziti and Stuffed Shells, carry a golden crust exterior that gives way to delectably tender interiors smothered in rich sauces.

The dining atmosphere at Two Paisan’s perfectly matches their culinary ethos: warm, unpretentious, and joyous. Whether grabbing a quick slice or picking up a full order for family and friends, the friendly service amplifies the welcoming vibe. Regular patrons rave about the genuine hospitality and the care evident in every interaction. It’s easy to feel like you’re joining a family gathering rather than just visiting a pizza joint.

With glowing reviews from customers like Mandy Sargent, who calls it a “holy wow” experience, and Brian Pichany, a full-blooded Italian who appreciates the “beam strength” of their crust and the authentic dough texture, Two Paisan’s proves it’s a beloved local gem. Jeff Lester’s enthusiastic “10/10 GUARANTEED A MUST STOP” endorsement and the genuine appreciation for unique wing sauces and specialty pies reinforce that this spot is more than just a convenient meal—it’s an experience worth savoring on every visit.

Whether it’s the richness of the chicken parm pasta, the satisfying crunch of their authentic pies, or the uplifting customer service, Two Paisan’s Pizzeria & Cafe delivers a taste of NYC right in Rochester. If you’re hungry for pizza that speaks to tradition and quality, look no further—this is your next go-to spot.

Contact: 4410 Lake Ave, Rochester, NY 14612 | Phone: +1 585-448-0001

Takeaway
Dine-in
Delivery

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Wheelchair-accessible car park

Credit cards
Debit cards

Mandy Sargent

27/11/2025

HOLY WOW. i could not wait to finish eating to write this review. for a family who EATS and eats more pizza than id like to admit- this pizza HITS! I have been on the hunt for a sincere NYC style pie, and I was not left with any disappointment. from the crust being the perfect combo of crunch and soft to the flavors of the homemade sauces and cheese, and the options for styles… it’s unmatched. was very sad when the slices were all gone! will be back- maybe even later today.

Brian Pichany

24/11/2025

I'm full blooded Italian, make pasta and Sunday sauce, grow the basil - the whole bit. I could tell (on the way home) that the pizza was going to be good; with the waft of cooked garlic and (yes) water in the dough; I can smell that. I'm a fan of pizza with beam strength, crust not too thick, crunchy underneath and at the edges, a decent amount of cheese, and the right amount of sauce. It hit all the marks! My wife and son agreed. They especially liked the Bianca pizza. We also got the a Pepperoni pizza. Fantastic! Ryan (I believe) said I'd be back. He's right.

Sue Mussaw

05/11/2025

I’m not even done eating and I’m leaving this review. 5 stars for sure! Friendly service on the phone and even friendlier upon arrival for pick up. We ordered a large margarita pizza and 10 wings with mannys special sauce. Both are out of this world. Perfect crust on the pizza! The wing sauce is a little hard to describe but man was it delicious! Worth checking out! We are thrilled that we tried them tonight! The margarita pizza could have used a little more basil but still 5 stars!!!!

Francheska Muniz

25/09/2025

I heard a lot of good things about this place so I went yesterday to try it out. 100/10 in everything! From the friendliest customer service, the food and the VIBES!! Pizza was AMAZING and the pattie with cheese and coco bread was delicious. This will definitely be my new pizza spot!

Jeff Lester

22/09/2025

Just had to give a shoutout to Two Paisan’s Pizzeria and Cafe is the BEST pizza in Rochester! The crust was perfect, the toppings were super fresh, and the staff was so friendly. You can tell they really care about what they do. If you haven’t tried them yet, do yourself a favor and go ASAP. 10/10 GUARANTEED A MUST STOP ! You won’t be disappointed !

James Mohrman

10/09/2025

Called the shop to order a pizza for my crew. Phone person was very polite and accommodating. Went to pick the food up the shop was clean and in order. The pizza was AMAZING, a true Brooklyn style crust, dough had a touch of sweetness and the sauce you could tell was made in house and made with love. This shop will be successful, get in line this place is going to be busy.

Abdul H

03/09/2025

Ordered a half Buffalo Chicken, half Alfredo Chicken Pizza and loved it. Always my go to whether im grabbing slices or a pizza.

Sherrie Timothy

29/08/2025

Stopped in to this new Gem in Charlotte for a few slices. Great service, pizza was delicious! Will definitely be back and looking forward to seeing them grow!

Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *